Home Prices Far Outpace Building Costs in B.C.

By Mata Press Service

The price of a newly built detached home in Vancouver averaged nearly five times its estimated construction cost between 2018 and 2025, the largest gap among 33 Canadian metropolitan areas examined in a new Fraser Institute study.

The report found that Vancouver's average selling price exceeded its estimated physical construction cost by 367.4 per cent over the eight-year period.

That means buyers were paying about $4.67 for every dollar reflected in reported construction values, a difference researchers say warrants closer scrutiny of land costs, government fees, housing regulations and restrictions on new development.

The study, authored by Austin Thompson, a senior policy analyst at the Fraser Institute, and Milagros Palacios, found that four of the five Canadian metropolitan areas with the largest gaps were in British Columbia.

Victoria ranked second nationally, with new detached homes selling for an average of 138.7 per cent above estimated construction costs, followed by Chilliwack at 128.9 per cent and Abbotsford-Mission at 123 per cent.

Kingston, Ontario, was the only community outside B.C. in the top five, recording a gap of 104 per cent.

"The sale price of a home will usually exceed the cost to physically build it, but in some Canadian cities, that gap is significant which points to how other cost drivers—such as land value, government charges, and burdensome red tape—can exacerbate the housing affordability crisis," Thompson said.

The findings add another dimension to Canada's housing affordability debate, where attention has focused on rising construction costs, high interest rates and housing shortages.

Across the 33 metropolitan areas examined, the median gap between selling prices and estimated construction costs was 72.4 per cent.

Toronto recorded a gap of 96.6 per cent, meaning newly built detached homes sold for almost twice their reported construction value.

Edmonton followed at 94.2 per cent and Calgary at 93.5 per cent, while Ottawa-Gatineau recorded 78.7 per cent.

Other B.C. communities also registered substantial differences, including Kelowna at 79.7 per cent, Nanaimo at 77.4 per cent and Kamloops at 62.5 per cent.

In contrast, Lethbridge, Alberta, and Drummondville, Quebec, recorded the smallest gaps, both at 11.1 per cent. Hamilton stood at 22.3 per cent, Quebec City at 32.5 per cent and Windsor at 37.5 per cent.

The Fraser Institute researchers examined building permit values reported by Statistics Canada and selling prices collected by the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation (CMHC).

Building permit values were used as an estimate of physical construction costs, including labour, materials and construction-related overhead.

The final selling price includes additional expenses such as land, development charges, financing, taxes and developer returns.

The researchers acknowledged that selling prices normally exceed physical construction costs because builders must purchase land, finance projects and earn a return on their investments.

However, they argued that exceptionally large and persistent gaps could indicate that restrictions on housing supply and other government-imposed costs are contributing to higher prices.

Among the factors examined were zoning restrictions, limited access to developable land, municipal approval delays, development charges and taxes.

The report cited separate research estimating that development charges for a typical low-rise housing project reached $180,300 per home in Toronto and $97,400 in Vancouver, compared with $31,600 in Edmonton and $9,900 in Winnipeg.

Approval delays can also increase expenses by forcing developers to carry financing costs longer while awaiting municipal decisions.

Another study cited in the report estimated approval timelines of 25 months in Toronto, compared with 10.1 months in Winnipeg and 3.4 months in Edmonton.

The researchers said these expenses can make some housing projects financially unviable, reducing the number of homes built and adding pressure to prices.

Vancouver's 367.4 per cent gap was more than two-and-a-half times the next-highest figure recorded in Victoria.

The report identifies several potential explanations, including land scarcity, geographical constraints, restrictions on what can be built and costs associated with obtaining development approvals.

Land values are particularly important because they can reflect both the desirability of a neighbourhood and restrictions on the number or type of homes permitted on a property.

The study notes that when governments limit housing density or restrict developable land, those policies can increase the value of properties where construction is allowed.

High demand can amplify those effects when new housing cannot be built quickly enough to meet buyers' needs.

However, the researchers acknowledged that their analysis does not establish precisely how much of the price gap is caused by government policy.

The study did not separately calculate land values, developer profits or the individual effects of taxes and regulations. It also did not adjust for differences in home size or quality between metropolitan areas.

Building permit values are estimates rather than verified final construction expenses, and homes sold in a particular year may have received their permits earlier.

The findings therefore cannot be interpreted as showing that the entire difference between construction values and selling prices represents excessive profits or unnecessary government costs.

The research also focused exclusively on new single-detached homes, excluding condominiums, townhouses and other multi-unit housing.

Nevertheless, Thompson and Palacios argued that the findings identify cities where government policies and market conditions deserve further investigation.

"In markets with significant gaps between home prices and construction costs, there is a strong case to closely examine how policy factors may be contributing to higher prices for Canadian homebuyers," Thompson said.

The researchers concluded that governments in high-gap cities should pay particular attention to policies governing developable land, zoning, building approvals, taxes and charges on new homes.

For Vancouver and several other B.C. communities, the differences were considerably greater than in most Canadian cities, suggesting that reducing physical construction costs alone may be insufficient to bring home prices within reach of more buyers.

Leave a comment
FACEBOOK TWITTER